|
Post by Penguin45 on Jan 21, 2017 19:29:01 GMT
They all do that, Sir. Custom designed by Torquemada, with extra input from Vlad the Impaler.
Figuring out a stop sounds like a sensible idea.
Chris.
|
|
|
Post by andrewa on Jan 22, 2017 7:52:11 GMT
Just wondered - run on valve any good?
|
|
|
Post by snoopy11 on Jan 22, 2017 9:58:50 GMT
It's made a small difference but not cured it. I've also tried colder plugs. That's not worked either.
What at have you tried to do to solve it?
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on Jan 22, 2017 12:22:17 GMT
The first thing to try is to reduce the idle speed, 100 rpm can make a difference. Even in the days of high octance leaded fuel a high idle could lead to running on with these engines especially after a long high speed run. Not so easy for Andrew with his hotter cam that probably needs a higher idle to run smoothly. To obtain a smooth lower idle requires there are no air leaks through the carb throttle spindle etc and that the crankcase emission system (including PCV where fitted) is working properly.
Maybe worth investing <£10 in an EBAY boroscope camera to see whether there is any carbon build up which can cause running on especially is the mixture is weak or the timing is out.
Plenty of discussion on the MGB sites as this is a common problem with the twin carbs and hotter cam requiring a higher idle setting than the single carb crab. I wonder if stale modern fuel may also be a factor?
Engaging 4th gear and applying the brakes as you turn off the engine works of course but isn't very elegant a solution!
regards
David
|
|
|
Post by snoopy11 on Jan 22, 2017 15:31:37 GMT
David
My engine is quite heavily modified. It's now 2 litre with a hot cam abd forged alloy Pistons. The head has also been done.
I think the problem both Andrew and I are having is the additional heat in the combustion chamber from the additional compression.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on Jan 23, 2017 0:48:19 GMT
Mark, my apologies, I should have recalled that you modified your engine with a fast road Kent cam, upgraded pistons etc. Having refreshed my memory, needed at my age , I see the cylinder head combustion chamber appears to have rounded off the sharp edges that can cause localised heating and running on as well as other issues. However, I see you had thought about rebuilding the carb but not sure if you got around to this. Also I see before the engine was rebuilt you had pinking and timing issues and were considering an Accuspark ignition unit or similar. Note the latter won't address timing issues but may be more reliable than points (or not!). With your engine's higher compression and hotter camshaft it would be even more critical to ensure the carb is in good condition and a revised needle used matched to the changed fuelling requirements. The ignition timing will also need to be revised, typically (often quite a bit) more advance at the lower end to suit the cam and get a decent idle, and almost certainly retarded at the mid to upper rpm range with less maximum advance. (If you haven't limited the maximum advance you may run the risk of serious engine damage). As each engine is different it is impossible to know by how much, but depending on which distributor you are using it could be 6 degrees or more, so quite considerable. Maybe Andrew can give you an indication of the settings on his programmable unit as some sort of an indicator. The distributor advance can be achieved by modifying the current distributor stop, springs and weights and it may also be necessary to change the vacuuum advance mechanism to avoid over advancing under less than wot. The alternative is to use a programmable unit such as Andrew's 123. Really the only way of getting it right is on a rolling road where they are familiar with these engines, such as offered by Peter Burgess. regards David Edit: I should have added that by increasing the advance at idle not only can you achieve a smoother tickover at a lower RPM, but this allows the butterfly to close further and that helps prevent run on by limiting the fuel. However, the downside is that you do need to modify the advance curve to ensure correct timing above idle and it can make the car harder to start. (I believe 123 and Alson Amethyst programmable units do provide for less advance when cranking to compensate). David My engine is quite heavily modified. It's now 2 litre with a hot cam abd forged alloy Pistons. The head has also been done. I think the problem both Andrew and I are having is the additional heat in the combustion chamber from the additional compression.
|
|
|
Post by andrewa on Jan 23, 2017 16:33:19 GMT
Running on had improved, but still had to wait 10/15 secs to switch off after high speed running! My latest visit to another rolling road has proved more productive in this regard - even if we then discovered I've probably done the head gasket! My modified engine tends to run lean at full chat so previous tuners have resolved this but it runs very rich at idle as a result. This most recent chap built up a graph of what was happening at different revs and was then able to overlay this with graphs from Burlen which showed precisely what each of their needles should do at different revs. Needless to say no one needle matched exactly but he was able to get very close and then modify it slightly. It helped that we were only a few miles from Burlen so were able to go back and forth sourcing the correct ones. I'm sure this is a factor as I'm sure all tuners don't carry all needles all the time! Anyway - no more running on - and no more running too rich at idle. Cheers A
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on Jan 23, 2017 23:53:14 GMT
That's very interesting, some running on! I hope the head gasket isn't damaged by the overheating from the weak mixture. In my opinion it shows that the scientific approach is the only real solution for a reliable and effective tune for a modified engine.
You are very lucky to have found a rolling road tuner with the level of knowledge to be able not only to select a needle but to modify it as well, it takes a lot of skill.
Did you find the cause for the valve timing changes you noted in an earlier post?
regards
David
|
|
|
Post by andrewa on Jan 24, 2017 6:10:32 GMT
LOL! I meant let it idle for 10/15 secs before switching off - not it kept on going!! No specific answer re cam timing - presume not right at the start - although much earlier post on here showed I thought it had slipped/moved - who knows. Re the engine/head - I'm somewhat philosophical- it's has 10,000 miles on it now and I'd estimate a large proportion of those miles were flat out. Will get head checked thoroughly and skimmed if necessary/valves lapped etc - also get them to ascertain exactly what compression ratio I'm running to make sure I'm getting best out of the cam. Received wisdom is spend a bit more and go for cometic gasket. It sounds like a lot of work but once heads off it's not. Just realised rabbitting on I've hi-jacked GLE's thread - apologies - bye! Andrew
|
|
|
Post by Penguin45 on Jan 26, 2017 23:57:11 GMT
He wants the twin carbs off my old engine and is talking to someone about fuel injection. Go figure... Might be interesting! Chris.
|
|
|
Post by snoopy11 on Jan 27, 2017 18:40:12 GMT
Snitch....
Yes. I've been talking to people. I need to decide if I'm going to stay with the single carb throttle body or go to a twin set up.
There red is an annoying oil leak I need to sort first though.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on Jan 28, 2017 0:33:06 GMT
Now where would those twin carbs have come from If you go for fuel injection that would make an interesting thread here but what would then happen to the twin carbs, a certain Penguin may try and recover them for his Princess maybe?. Lots of challenges ahead. regards David
|
|
|
Post by Penguin45 on Jan 28, 2017 0:45:48 GMT
I think I've arrived at a point where I can let the twin carbs go. There is a marginal advantage on long runs with regard to fuel consumption, but they were pretty shocking around town. Besides, as you keep saying, I haven't got the cam to match the twin carbs, so it was always a compromise. The Red Dog is the "keeper", so longer term the plan is to get Eugenie tidied up and moved on.
What I would like is the dizzy from the engine being replaced. That was a refurbished unit and the one on the Red Dog has got a shot bearing. Rotor wobbles about all over the place. Scatter timing....
Chris.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on Jan 28, 2017 3:07:21 GMT
Oh no! Penguins and ignition not a happy mix! If you look at the original Motor article back in 1964 the Mk1 1800 specific fuel consumptiono was some 20 to 40% better than the MGB from 2000 to 4000 rpm. David What I would like is the dizzy from the engine being replaced. That was a refurbished unit and the one on the Red Dog has got a shot bearing. Rotor wobbles about all over the place. Scatter timing.... Chris.
|
|
wolseley1800
Member
Posts: 127
Attribute: The Voice of Doom!
|
Post by wolseley1800 on Apr 17, 2017 21:23:41 GMT
Things are afoot. Mark having fun Bit of a teaser
|
|