|
Post by dave1800 on May 15, 2014 2:29:14 GMT
Hi Tommy As far as the distributor is concerned why not speak / email Distributor Doctor for some expert advice? Has anyone ever used the petrol tank sealant as a means of preventing rust particles or is it fraught with more problems than it's worth? Have you checked the piston drop time is within spec if it won't work well with the original oil which I believe is a straight 20W. Any news about the tight tappets? Regards David Well, I've done some research again and I believe there are more than one single thing playing up. Not easy to diagnose, but I try to substitute one thing at the time. Biggest improvement came from going back to the old distributor, rather than the one overhauled by DD. Strange in deed, but I'm starting to believe there's something not right with the rebuilt one. There were identical problems when using it on the blue car, too. Not sure what to to about it. No use of a rebuilt one that's not working as it should. Other things I've found: The car, or perhaps rather the NOS carb, does not like the original SU dashpot oil. It seems too thin. Far better response and less jerky with 20w50. Quite a lot of rust/ debris has collected in quite a short time in the float chamber bottom. It's very fine, sand like stuff. If I stirr the petrol in the chamber, it will get all rust coloured. You'd think it would end some time, I've driven it every day for over a year.. Anyway, Ive installed a filter right after the tank and even after a short trip a visible collection of the debris was trapped in the filter.. Will get back later.. Tommy
|
|
|
Post by tommydp on May 15, 2014 17:37:25 GMT
Yes, I will contact him but want to make sure the distributor is a problem first. So far, it seems like it too me.
I'll check the drop time of the carb piston too. I think the SU oil is 20 W.
Checked the valve clearances again now, as the engine is cold. What is now clear is that at least three valves have symptoms of a slightly bent/ worn pushrod/ worn rocker adjuster ball/ worn tappets. That is, the valve clearance changes while rotating the valve's pushrod. Valve number 5 was the worst. The clearance changes from a loose to a very tight 0.015, just by rotating the pushrod. I'm really annoyed I didn't check this earlier..
I'll try to overcome this with another pushrod/ adjuster ball on the affected valves and at least adjust the clearances so that they are not too tight at any position of the pushrod.
Tommy.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on May 16, 2014 3:57:43 GMT
Maybe worth having a look at the rocker shaft as the primary culprit. Crabmaster posted an excellent photo of the wear he found rocker shaft and I've read about similar issues on MGB forum. Regards David EDIT: Sorry, I've just re-read your post so the rocker shaft isn't the primary suspect but still worth checking. When you rotate the pushrods did you free them from the tappets or are they turning too perhaps and part of the issue? David Checked the valve clearances again now, as the engine is cold. What is now clear is that at least three valves have symptoms of a slightly bent/ worn pushrod/ worn rocker adjuster ball/ worn tappets. That is, the valve clearance changes while rotating the valve's pushrod. Valve number 5 was the worst. The clearance changes from a loose to a very tight 0.015, just by rotating the pushrod. I'm really annoyed I didn't check this earlier.. I'll try to overcome this with another pushrod/ adjuster ball on the affected valves and at least adjust the clearances so that they are not too tight at any position of the pushrod. Tommy.
|
|
|
Post by tommydp on May 17, 2014 22:09:40 GMT
Hi all!
Been through everything now, and it still refuses to go up hills without hesitating and lacking power.
End of story is I've now put it up for sale! Just fed up..
Hope you've got more luck with the crabs than I seem to have:-)
Tommy.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on May 18, 2014 0:07:32 GMT
Hi Tommy I can almost feel your frustration which I understand. I guess many of us here have been there! It's a pity I just can't pop round to try and give you a hand. Seriously though, are there any (reasonably)local mini or MGB clubs with tuning experts? Do any of the garages have the old style CRT Sun style diagnostics equipment which could almost instantly show up the problem to an experienced operator. In the meantime I think it is time for a few beers, but not cigarettes. . Did you ever get the Peter Burgess cylinder head? There IS a solution, sleep on it. Regards David EDIT: If your car is down on power climbing hills and you are absolutely sure there is no fuel starvation then it is either an ignition - probably timing - fault or the engine which is basically an air pump isn't taking in sufficient air /fuel. The timing can be checked against the crankshaft pulley with a timing light at say 3,000 rpm AND double check that the pulley TDC mark really is correct and that the harmonic damper rubber hasn't failed allowing it to twist. As your compression is good at cranking speed (cold) and you have double checked the tappets the next thing to check is that the camshaft lobes aren't worn, not common on genuine BMC camshafts but possible. You can check this by observing and measuring the rocker arm movement. Worn lobes won't normally show up by changes in tappet clearances as you take the measurement opposite the lobe. Finally are you sure the exhaust isn't partially blocked, look at the vacuum gauge for clues. You have probably done all this many times but if not I hope this helps ....good luck! Hi all! Been through everything now, and it still refuses to go up hills without hesitating and lacking power. End of story is I've now put it up for sale! Just fed up.. Hope you've got more luck with the crabs than I seem to have:-) Tommy.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on May 18, 2014 10:43:42 GMT
Tommy
Some more thoughts. You noted the issue of the valve clearance changing while rotating the pushrods. Are you sure you don't have a bent pushrod(s) which would suggest valve(s) sticking. If just binding a little when the engine is under load (when it is at its hottest) this would reduce the power and cause the stuttering which would go away again as soon as you eased off. Easily checked with your vacuum gauge connected while you drive, take the car up a steep hill until it stutters and then immediately watch the gauge on idle before it cools at all.
David
|
|
|
Post by tommydp on May 18, 2014 20:37:35 GMT
Thank you so much, Dave! I needed that, and the beers...
Well, it's advertised, but the ad says "Thinking about selling".. I just don't think I can manage to see it go.. After all, the car is 44 yrs old, and it's actually been on duty everyday for a year. With little problems, all in all.
I took it to a Cars&coffee event today. Lots of MGs, Jags etc as it actually was a "British" day. It had lots of attention, and I spoke to lots of nice people and made some contacts with people who are really into UK classics. Great, as I've really missed some other enthusiasts to discuss things with when facing car trouble. By all means, forum is great, but real life is something else.
So, a great day. It ran very well today, even overtaking a XJ 6 uphill in 80 kmh:-)
The fact that it changes is quite frustrating. I think I'll have to get a head serviced by Burgess. I haven't got around doing it yet. I'm quite sure there's a valve/ pushrod etc playing up still.
I changed the pushrods on those valves with valve clearance issues, so perhaps it's improving. Could be a valve sticking occasionally. I'll install a vacuum gauge permanently, and watch it on the road. What I noticed today, when it ran fine, was that it had a more even exhaust note at idle. Felt it with my hand. When it's playing up, there's more of a regular sound which seems to match the tick of a valve.
All in all, I may be over picky.. I thought of that while watching the other classics. Lots of ticking and rattling, petrol and exhaust smell and some really lumpy idling sounds..
An MGB owner said the 1800 ran as sweetly as a Rolls:-) Happy with that, but I want it to do it's best all the time:-)
Updates will come:-)
Tommy
|
|
|
Post by Nick RS on May 18, 2014 21:53:47 GMT
Tommy, Glad you had a good day. I've found that a positive comment from someone at a show or even in the street about the car has renewed my enthusiasm.
Nick
|
|
|
Post by andrewa on May 19, 2014 7:20:47 GMT
I had a fair few of the symptoms you mention on my brand new engine, Distributor Dr Dizzy, brand new SU carb from Burlen etc ! Cured them all on a rolling road in an hour - it was just setting it up - difficulty is not finding rolling road, but someone who knows A/B series tuning inside out - there are not as many around as you would think! Good luck, don't sell! Cheers Andrew
|
|
|
Post by Penguin45 on May 19, 2014 23:26:36 GMT
Tommy, Having a chat with other owners, or like-minded people at car shows is always a bit of a boost when things are not going to plan. I'd say take a bit of time with this. I got the impression that the white car was "The One", so it must be worth spending a bit of time on. My one will (very) occasionally shake and judder for no reason that I've ever managed to work out. I'm at the stage now where I just ignore it, as it goes away again.... The basic problem is that everything is 40 years old at least and there is little truly "new" stock about. Your new distributor will be built on a 40 year old casting, even if the insides are new. Bit of patience, bit of logic, bit of informnation and bullying from David - you'll get this sorted, I'm sure. Cheers, Chris.
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on May 20, 2014 2:39:16 GMT
Oh dear, I am a bully now . I like to think of it as structured encouragement a bit like old fashioned teaching, Tommy, if you read your history books! Chris is right, we need to remember these cars are 40 years old. I see Andrewa used a rolling road to set his car up. This is an expensive and in my view an unnecessary outlay for a standard Landcrab engine, but his car has a non standard cam and other mods which more than justifies his decision as he is concerned with performance. He noted it was difficult to find people with A and B series tuning experience but there is nothing to be frightened of. My experience, over too many years, with A and B series engines is that the standard single carb Landcrab B series engine is extremely tolerant and actually very easy to set up. It may take a bit more skill to get the best out of it, but easy to get running pretty well. However, the ignition system components especially must be in good condition which I know can pose an issue nowadays. I have noted previously I have run cars with 200K miles or more on the original carb, of course with leaks on the throttle spindle, original distributor and head. Yes, they burned oil and that was really the only symptom, they ran well with no spluttering and not that much loss of performance even up long hills. I always checked that the carb piston ran free and converted spring carb needles back to the original design to avoid jet wear. Before any attempt is made to tune any engine the first task is to measure the compression and this is true of the Landcrab too. You cannot achieve the impossible; a worn engine will show lower compression but as long as it is reasonably even across the cylinders (10% is often quoted but this engine can accept more in my experience)then you are not wasting your time. As Chris says, apply logic - eventually you will get there - even in the case of Chris' Wolseley's occasional misfire I have just had a problem with the engine on my Toyota D4D that only shows for the first 30 seconds on start up. Nothing shows on reading the fault codes or computer monitoring the engine running, so it's back to basics again. Just that I have to wait at least 12 hours between checks for the engine to cool down completely, so I fully understand the meaning of the word "frustration" and applying logic. The electrical system manual runs to >1000 pages so great fun. This morning it started with no symptom, have I cured it; I don't know! So, hang in there Tommy! David Tommy, Bit of patience, bit of logic, bit of information and bullying from David - you'll get this sorted, I'm sure. Cheers, Chris.
|
|
|
Post by tommydp on May 20, 2014 16:14:51 GMT
Hi all! Thanks a lot for all kind replies. I really appreciate it!
Well, it seems to have improved. Was excellent all day Sunday, but struggling again going to work yesterday. Was fine going to work this morning.. All in all, I'd say it seems to be getting better. Perhaps the attention it got at the show did the trick! I'm sure it had as much, if not more, attention than the E- type, Lotus, MGAs etc.. One guy almost burst into tears, as his wedding car had been his uncle's white 1800 mk 2.
So what have I done? I got back to the old carburettor and distributor, and as the symptoms remained I think they can be ruled out. The most drastic change has been changing the pushrods on three valves, all of which had changing valve clearances while turning the pushrod around. From a very loose slide, to quite tight. With other pushrods the clearances stayed the same while turning the pushrods. Then I adjusted the valvs againg, of course.
Also, the filter I installed at the tank collects quite a lot of very fine rust debris. If I shake it, the fuel inside goes all brown. I actually think I'll have to change it, after only a week. I've observed the debris, which collected at the bottom of the float bowl of the carb I removed (no filter then). The debris seems to stick together, and I believe it could make issues in the plastic pipe from float to jet.
I'll just drive it now, and see. I think it boils down to a fuel supply problem, due to rust from the tank or a valve/ lifter issue like a sticking valve. The compression is actually spot on 190 on all cylinders, cold, and I can't say I found anything strange about the valves when I had the head off.
Regards, Tommy
|
|
|
Post by andrewa on May 20, 2014 16:26:26 GMT
Cool - glad to hear - had similar problem of old tank/fuel/muck in float chamber on an old motorbike.....running it under load with the choke out seemed to clear it, but I'm sure there's a more professional approach! Glad you're sort of back in love. Andrew
|
|
|
Post by dave1800 on May 21, 2014 0:17:41 GMT
Tommy
Good to hear you are a bit happier! Out of interest do you know if the cylinder head has been converted to running on unleaded fuel?
David
|
|
|
Post by tommydp on May 21, 2014 15:26:59 GMT
I'm not sure about the cylinder head. It sure looked original and untouched to me. I'll get a new fuel filter this evening. Otherwise I think I'll just drive it as it is now, and see how things go.
Regards, Tommy.
|
|